How Impact-Resistant Are Shingles? 7 Factors to Consider

When it comes to protecting your home, the type of shingles you choose is of utmost importance. From withstanding harsh weather conditions to maintaining their integrity over time, impact-resistant shingles are designed specifically to tackle these challenges.

In this article, we’ll dive deep into the world of impact-resistant shingles, hosting a comprehensive exploration of their advantages, what to look for when buying, and how they fare against their regular counterparts.

How impact-resistant are shingles?

Shingles are designed to provide a certain level of impact resistance, but the exact level can vary depending on the specific type and brand of shingles. Impact-resistant shingles are typically made with a reinforced fiberglass mat or rubberized asphalt, which helps to absorb and distribute the force of impacts.

These shingles are tested to meet specific industry standards for impact resistance, such as UL 2218 or FM 4473. The ratings range from Class 1 to Class 4, with Class 4 having the highest level of impact resistance. Class 4 shingles are able to withstand impacts from large hailstones and are less prone to damage from falling debris.

However, no shingles are completely indestructible, and severe impacts can still cause damage. It’s always recommended to consult with roofing professionals and consider local weather conditions when selecting shingles for your specific needs.

7 Factors to consider when buying impact-resistant shingles

1. Climate and weather conditions

Considering the climate and weather conditions of your area is important when selecting impact-resistant shingles. Different regions experience varying levels of extreme weather, such as high winds, hailstorms, or heavy rain. Understanding the specific weather patterns in your location will help you choose shingles that are designed to withstand those conditions effectively.

2. Impact resistance rating

Pay attention to the impact resistance rating of the shingles you are considering. Shingles are tested and rated based on their ability to withstand impacts from hailstones and other debris. Look for shingles that have a higher impact resistance rating, such as Class 3 or Class 4, if you live in an area prone to severe weather or have concerns about falling objects.

3. Material and construction

Different materials and construction techniques can affect the impact resistance of shingles. Some impact-resistant shingles are made with a reinforced fiberglass mat or rubberized asphalt, which enhances their durability. Understanding the composition of the shingles can help you assess their ability to withstand impacts and make an informed decision.

4. Warranty coverage

Review the manufacturer’s warranty policy for impact-resistant shingles. A thorough warranty can give you peace of mind and defense against any potential impact damage. Pay attention to the specific terms and conditions of the warranty, including any limitations or exclusions that may apply.

5. Installation requirements

Proper installation is crucial to ensuring the effectiveness of impact-resistant shingles. Consider consulting with professional roofers who have experience installing these types of shingles. They can provide guidance on the correct installation techniques, including proper fastening methods and any additional measures that may be required for optimal impact resistance.

6. Aesthetics and design options

While impact resistance is important, you also want your shingles to enhance the overall appearance of your home. Look for impact-resistant shingles that come in a variety of colors, styles, and designs to match your personal preferences and architectural style. It’s possible to find shingles that combine both durability and aesthetics.

7. Budget considerations

Impact-resistant shingles may have a higher upfront cost compared to standard shingles due to their enhanced durability and performance. Consider your budget when selecting shingles and weigh the long-term benefits against the initial investment. Remember that investing in higher-quality, impact-resistant shingles can potentially save you money in the long run by reducing the need for repairs or replacements.

Types of shingles and their impact-resistance

  • Asphalt shingles: Asphalt shingles are commonly used and come in various styles and designs. They typically offer good impact resistance, but the level may vary depending on the specific brand and quality.
  • Metal shingles: Metal shingles are known for their durability and can provide excellent impact resistance. They are designed to withstand hail, falling debris, and high winds, making them a popular choice in areas prone to severe weather.
  • Rubber shingles: Rubber shingles are made from recycled materials and offer good impact resistance. They can effectively absorb and distribute the force of impacts, making them suitable for areas with hail or heavy rainfall.
  • Fiberglass shingles: Fiberglass shingles are lightweight and offer decent impact resistance. They are constructed with a fiberglass mat that provides strength and durability, making them a common choice for residential roofing.
  • Composite shingles: Composite shingles are a blend of different materials, such as asphalt, fiberglass, or rubber. Depending on the specific composition, they can offer varying levels of impact resistance. You need to check the product specifications for the impact resistance rating.
  • Slate shingles: Slate shingles are highly durable and have good impact resistance. They are made from natural stone and can withstand severe weather conditions, including hailstorms and strong winds. However, they tend to be more expensive compared to other types of shingles.
  • Wood shingles: Wood shingles, such as cedar, are aesthetically pleasing but generally have lower impact resistance compared to other materials. While they can withstand minor impacts, they may be more susceptible to damage from severe weather conditions.

Role of material in shingle’s impact-resistance

Different materials have varying properties that can affect their ability to withstand impacts. For example, shingles made from metal or rubberized asphalt tend to offer excellent impact resistance due to their inherent durability and flexibility. Metal shingles are often engineered to withstand hail, falling debris, and high winds. Rubberized asphalt shingles are designed to absorb and distribute the force of impacts, making them more resistant to damage.

Fiberglass shingles, on the other hand, are lightweight yet strong, providing a level of impact resistance. Wood shingles, while aesthetically pleasing, generally have lower impact resistance compared to other materials. Understanding the material properties and their impact resistance characteristics can help homeowners make informed decisions when selecting shingles that can withstand the specific weather conditions and potential impacts in their area.

Impact of weather on impact-resistance of shingles

Extreme weather events such as hailstorms, heavy rain, high winds, and falling debris can put shingles to the test. Shingles that are specifically designed to be impact-resistant are constructed to withstand these types of weather conditions. They may incorporate features such as reinforced fiberglass mats or rubberized asphalt to enhance their ability to absorb and distribute the force of impacts.

Try to focus on the climate and weather patterns in your area when selecting impact-resistant shingles. Different regions may experience varying levels of severe weather, and choosing shingles that are appropriate for your specific climate can help ensure their longevity and ability to withstand impacts over time.

Regular maintenance and inspections are also recommended to identify and address any damage that may occur due to weather-related factors, helping to maintain the impact resistance of the shingles.

Industry standards for impact-resistant shingles

The industry has established specific standards to assess the impact resistance of shingles. Two widely recognized standards are UL 2218 and FM 4473. Underwriters Laboratories developed the testing standard known as UL 2218 to assess how well roofing materials withstand impacts from steel balls of various sizes dropped from predetermined heights.

The standard assigns shingles a rating from Class 1 to Class 4, with Class 4 having the highest level of impact resistance. Another widely used standard that evaluates the impact resistance of roofing materials is FM 4473, developed by FM Global. It also assigns shingles a rating from Class 1 to Class 4, with Class 4 indicating the highest level of impact resistance.

These standards provide a benchmark for manufacturers and consumers to evaluate and compare the impact resistance of different shingles, helping to make sure they meet certain performance criteria and can withstand potential damage from hailstones or falling debris.

Testing methodology for impact-resistant shingles

Standard testing for impact-resistant shingles involves putting them through controlled impact tests to see how well they can handle being hit by hailstones or other objects. The specific testing procedures may vary depending on the standards followed, such as UL 2218 or FM 4473.

In these tests, shingle samples are typically installed on a test deck and subjected to the impact of steel balls dropped from specified heights. The balls vary in size and are dropped multiple times at different locations on the shingle surface. After the impacts, the shingles are inspected for any signs of damage, such as cracks, fractures, or punctures.

The severity of the damage is then evaluated and used to assign the shingles a rating based on the established classification system. The testing methodology aims to simulate real-world conditions and provide an objective measure of the shingles’ impact resistance, allowing manufacturers and consumers to make informed decisions about their performance and suitability for different weather conditions.

Commercially available impact-resistant shingles

  • GAF ArmorShield II
  • CertainTeed Landmark IR
  • Owens Corning Duration Storm
  • Tamko Heritage Impact Resistant
  • Malarkey Legacy

These impact-resistant shingles are commercially available and offered by various manufacturers. They are designed to provide enhanced durability and impact resistance, incorporating features such as reinforced fiberglass mats, rubberized asphalt, or other advanced materials. These shingles typically meet industry standards for impact resistance, such as UL 2218 or FM 4473.

They also come in a variety of styles, colors, and designs to match different architectural preferences. When selecting impact-resistant shingles, it is recommended to consult with roofing professionals or refer to manufacturer specifications to choose the most suitable option based on your specific needs and budget.

Comparative analysis: Impact-resistant shingles vs regular shingles

FactorImpact-Resistant ShinglesRegular Asphalt ShinglesRegular Metal ShinglesRegular Wood Shingles
Impact Resistance RatingClass 3 or Class 4VariesVariesVaries
Material and ConstructionReinforced fiberglass mat or rubberized asphaltAsphalt and fiberglassMetalWood
DurabilityEnhanced durability and ability to withstand impactsModerateModerate to HighModerate
Weather ResistanceDesigned to withstand severe weather conditions and resist damage from hail and falling debrisModerateHighModerate
LongevityCan have a longer lifespan due to enhanced durabilityVariesVariesVaries
AestheticsAvailable in various styles, colors, and designs to match architectural preferencesVariesVariesDistinctive and natural look
CostGenerally higher upfront cost compared to regular shingles, but potential long-term savings from reduced repairs or replacementsVariesVariesVaries

First, impact-resistant shingles have higher impact resistance ratings, typically classified as Class 3 or Class 4, indicating their ability to withstand impacts from hail and falling debris. This is achieved through the use of reinforced fiberglass mats or rubberized asphalt in their construction. Impact-resistant shingles also demonstrate enhanced durability, making them more resistant to damage and potentially extending their lifespan.

They are designed to withstand severe weather conditions, providing greater weather resistance compared to regular shingles. Impact-resistant shingles come in a variety of styles, colors, and designs, allowing homeowners to choose options that match their architectural preferences.

The cost of impact-resistant shingles is generally higher upfront compared to regular shingles, but this investment may result in long-term savings by reducing the need for repairs or replacements.

Maintenance tips for impact-resistant shingles

  • Regular inspections: Conduct regular visual inspections of your impact-resistant shingles to identify any signs of damage or wear. Look for cracks, fractures, or other issues that may compromise their impact resistance.
  • Clear debris: Keep your roof clear of debris such as leaves, twigs, and branches. Debris accumulation can trap moisture and potentially lead to damage over time.
  • Trim overhanging branches: Trim any overhanging branches near your roof to minimize the risk of falling debris during storms or high winds that could impact your shingles.
  • Clean gutters and downspouts: Regularly clean your gutters and downspouts to ensure proper drainage. Clogged gutters can cause water backup and potential damage to your shingles.
  • Address moss or algae growth: If you notice moss or algae growth on your shingles, take steps to address it promptly. These organisms can trap moisture and compromise the integrity of the shingles.
  • Avoid walking on shingles. Minimize foot traffic on your roof to prevent unnecessary stress or damage to the impact-resistant shingles. If maintenance or repairs are required, consider hiring professionals who have experience working with impact-resistant roofing materials.
  • Promptly address repairs: If you notice any damage or issues with your impact-resistant shingles, address them promptly. Repairing small problems early can help prevent further damage and maintain the shingles’ impact resistance over time.

Final verdict: Are impact-resistant shingles worth it?

If you live in an area prone to severe weather conditions such as hailstorms or high winds, then impact-resistant shingles are worth considering. They are specifically designed to withstand these types of impacts and provide added protection for your roof.

If you are concerned about potential damage from falling debris, then impact-resistant shingles can offer peace of mind. They are more resilient to damage from debris due to their increased durability and impact resistance.

If you are looking for long-term cost savings, then investing in impact-resistant shingles may be worth it. While they may have a higher upfront cost compared to regular shingles, their ability to withstand impacts can potentially reduce the need for frequent repairs or replacements, saving you money in the long run.

If you value the aesthetics of your home, then impact-resistant shingles can be a good option. They come in various styles, colors, and designs, allowing you to choose shingles that enhance the overall appearance of your property while still providing the desired impact resistance.

If you want to maximize the lifespan of your roof, then impact-resistant shingles can be beneficial. Their durability and ability to withstand impacts can contribute to a longer lifespan compared to regular shingles, potentially reducing the need for premature roof replacement.

However, if you live in an area with mild weather conditions and minimal risk of impacts, then regular shingles may be sufficient for your needs. Impact-resistant shingles may not provide significant additional benefits in such cases.

Ultimately, the decision on whether impact-resistant shingles are worth it depends on your specific circumstances, budget, and priorities. Considering factors such as your location, weather patterns, potential risks, and personal preferences will help you make an informed choice about whether the investment in impact-resistant shingles is justified for your situation.

Logan
Author: Logan

I help people connect with businesses