When Should I Buy a New Toilet: 7 Clear Signs

Toilets, while not usually the most glamorous topic of conversation, are fundamental components of every household. Knowing when it’s time to replace your old toilet can save you money, enhance your comfort, and even help the environment.

In this article, we’ll guide you through understanding the signs of a toilet in decline, the benefits of replacement, and important factors to consider when purchasing a new toilet.

Table of contents

When should I buy a new toilet?

You should consider buying a new toilet when you notice persistent issues that are not resolved by regular repairs. These can include constant clogs, cracks in the porcelain, a wobbly base, or if the toilet frequently requires multiple flushes.

If you’re undergoing a bathroom renovation or if your toilet is considerably old and you’re looking to improve water efficiency, it might be time to purchase a new model.

Environmental consideration is also a valid reason, as newer models tend to be more water-efficient, which can lead to significant savings on your water bill.

7 clear signs it’s time to replace your old toilet

1. Persistent clogging

No one likes dealing with a clogged toilet. While occasional clogs can happen, if your toilet seems to be giving you trouble on a regular basis, it may be time to replace it. Frequent clogs can be a sign of a serious issue, such as a hidden blockage in the plumbing system or an old, low-flush toilet that’s simply not up to the task anymore.

2. Cracks in the porcelain

A visual inspection of your toilet can reveal cracks in the porcelain of the tank or bowl. These cracks may cause leaks, leading to water damage in your bathroom. Even if they aren’t leaking yet, they could start at any time. It’s also possible for these cracks to cause a catastrophic failure where the tank or bowl breaks, causing a major flood.

3. Wobbling toilet

A toilet should be firmly anchored to the floor. If it wobbles when you sit on it, this could indicate a problem with the mounting bolts. It could also signify a more serious issue, like a rotting floor underneath. If tightening the bolts doesn’t solve the problem, it’s likely time for a new toilet.

4. Frequent repairs

If you find yourself frequently calling a plumber to repair the toilet, it might be more cost-effective to replace it outright. The money spent on parts and labor for regular repairs could go towards the cost of a new, more reliable model.

5. A high water bill

Older toilets use a lot of water compared to newer models. If you notice your water bill is unusually high, your toilet could be the culprit. Newer models have improved water efficiency drastically. Investing in a new toilet could save you money in the long run.

6. Surface damage

Over time, scratches can develop on the surface of the bowl. These scratches make it harder to keep clean and can become breeding grounds for bacteria. When cleaning becomes strenuous or ineffective, replacing the toilet is often a better solution.

7. Outdated design

If you’re renovating your bathroom, it’s a good time to consider upgrading your toilet too. An outdated toilet can detract from the overall look and feel of the room. Plus, newer models offer advanced features like increased water efficiency and comfort enhancements that your old toilet simply may not have.

What are the signs of a worn-out or damaged toilet?

Frequent clogging: A toilet that gets clogged regularly even without misuse could be a sign of wear and tear or design flaws.
Cracks: Visible cracks in the porcelain, either on the toilet bowl or tank, can be a sign of damage. While some may appear minor, they can grow over time, leading to leaks and potential water damage.
Constant running water: If your toilet is constantly running water into the bowl, it may indicate an issue with the internal components, such as a faulty flapper, fill valve, or overflow tube.

Inefficient flushing: If you often need to flush multiple times to clear the bowl, your toilet could be worn out or inefficient.
Water around the base: If you notice water pooling around the base of your toilet, it could be due to a worn-out wax ring seal, a cracked bowl, or a loose tank.
Wobbling: A toilet that rocks or wobbles when you sit on it may have loose bolts or, more seriously, a damaged floor underneath.

Outdated or inefficient design: If your toilet is old and uses more water per flush than modern models, it may be considered worn out due to its inefficiency and environmental impact.

Can I repair or upgrade my current toilet instead of buying a new one?

Yes, depending on the issue, you may be able to repair or upgrade your current toilet instead of buying a new one.

Simple issues like a running toilet or occasional clogs can often be fixed with replacement parts. There are also upgrade options available, such as installing a dual-flush converter for improved water efficiency or adding a bidet attachment for added hygiene.

However, if the toilet has serious issues like cracks in the porcelain, frequent clogs, or a wobbly base due to a rotten floor underneath, it’s usually more cost-effective and safer to replace it entirely.

Similarly, if you’re looking to significantly improve water efficiency or modernize an outdated design, a new toilet would be a better option.

When is a professional opinion necessary for toilet replacement?

It’s advisable to seek a professional opinion for toilet replacement when you’re dealing with persistent issues that aren’t resolved by simple repairs, such as constant clogs, noticeable cracks in the porcelain, or a wobbly base that could indicate a damaged floor.

A professional plumber can accurately diagnose these problems and recommend whether a repair or a complete replacement is necessary.

Also, if you’re considering a toilet upgrade as part of a larger bathroom renovation, a professional can provide valuable advice on the best options according to your needs and budget. They can also ensure that the installation is done correctly to avoid future problems.

How does water efficiency impact my decision to replace a toilet?

Water efficiency plays a significant role in the decision to replace a toilet. Older toilet models can use anywhere from 3.5 to 7 gallons of water per flush, while newer, high-efficiency models use as little as 1.28 gallons per flush.

This difference can add up to thousands of gallons of water saved each year, translating into significant savings on your water bill. Besides the financial aspect, there’s also an environmental factor to consider.

Using a water-efficient toilet helps conserve a vital natural resource, which is particularly important in areas prone to drought or with water usage restrictions.

Therefore, even if your old toilet is functioning adequately, you might opt to replace it with a water-efficient model to save money and contribute to environmental conservation.

What are the long-term financial benefits of replacing my toilet?

Lower water bills: Modern toilets are designed to be water-efficient. They use significantly less water per flush compared to older models, leading to substantial savings on your water bill over time.
Fewer repair costs: If your old toilet frequently requires repairs, those costs can add up. A new toilet will likely need fewer repairs, saving you money on maintenance costs in the long run.
Increased home value: If you plan on selling your home in the future, a new, modern toilet can increase your home’s appeal to potential buyers and may contribute to a higher selling price.

Energy savings: Some modern toilets have features like heated seats or built-in bidets, which are energy efficient and could lead to savings on your energy bill.
Potential rebates: In some areas, local utilities offer rebates for installing water-efficient appliances, including toilets. This can offset the initial cost of the toilet.

How do new toilets differ in design and functionality?

Water efficiency: Modern toilets are much more water-efficient compared to older models. They use significantly less water per flush, which not only saves money on water bills but also helps conserve water.

Dual flush: Many new toilets come with a dual flush option, allowing you to choose between a full or partial flush depending on the waste. This feature provides further water savings.
Comfort height: Newer toilets often offer ‘comfort height’ designs, which are a bit taller than standard toilets, making them more comfortable for adults, especially the elderly or those with mobility issues.
One-piece vs. two-piece: Modern toilets come in one-piece and two-piece designs. One-piece toilets have the tank and bowl integrated into one unit, offering a sleek look and easier cleaning. Two-piece toilets have a separate tank and bowl.

Eco-friendly features: Some contemporary toilets come with eco-friendly features, like composting abilities or built-in bidets, which reduce toilet paper usage.
Advanced features: High-end modern toilets may offer advanced features like heated seats, automatic lid opening and closing, self-cleaning capabilities, night lights, and even Bluetooth connectivity for playing music.

What materials and brands offer the best quality and durability?

Toilets are typically made from porcelain, also known as vitreous china, which is popular for its durability, easy maintenance, and classic look. However, the quality and durability of a toilet also depend greatly on the brand and model.

TOTO: TOTO is a well-known Japanese brand with a reputation for high-quality, durable toilets. They offer a wide range of styles and models, including the popular TOTO Drake and the high-end TOTO Neorest with advanced features.
Kohler: An American brand with over 140 years in the industry, Kohler is known for its high-quality and durable products. They offer a wide range of designs, from classic to modern.
American Standard: This brand has been around for over 140 years and is known for its reliable and durable toilets. Their Champion 4 model is particularly praised for its performance and durability.

Duravit is a German brand known for its innovative designs and high-quality products. Duravit offers a range of stylish, durable toilets, including wall-mounted and floor-standing models.
Niagara Conservation is known for making some of the most water-efficient toilets on the market without compromising on performance. Their products are durable and eco-friendly.

How do I choose the right toilet for my bathroom space and style?

Choosing the right toilet involves considering the size of your bathroom, the style of your decor, and your personal preferences.

For smaller bathrooms, consider a compact, round-front, or wall-mounted toilet to save space.

For larger bathrooms, an elongated or comfort-height toilet could add a touch of luxury. The style of your toilet should also match your decor; a sleek, one-piece design might suit a modern bathroom, while a two-piece with traditional detailing may be better for a classic style.

Don’t forget about color; while white is the most common, toilets come in a range of colors to match any palette.

Finally, consider special features like dual-flush or water-saving technology, soft-close lids, or even built-in bidets for added functionality and comfort.

What environmental factors should I consider when purchasing a new toilet?

When purchasing a new toilet, there are several environmental factors to consider. The most significant is water efficiency. Modern toilets use far less water per flush than older models, which not only conserves a vital natural resource but also reduces the energy used in water treatment facilities.

Look for models with a WaterSense label that meet the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s criteria for efficiency and performance. If possible, choose a dual-flush toilet, which uses less water for liquid waste and more for solid waste.

Some toilets also have eco-friendly features like composting capabilities or built-in bidets, which reduce the need for toilet paper—another environmental plus. By considering these factors, you can make a purchase that not only meets your needs but also contributes to the wellbeing of the planet.

What are the steps to the proper installation of a new toilet?

1. Prepare the area

Start by removing the old toilet if it’s still in place. Then clean the flange, which is the ring that holds the toilet in place on the floor. Make sure there’s no leftover wax or other debris.

2. Install the new wax ring

Place a new wax ring on the flange. This creates a watertight seal between the toilet and the drain pipe.

3. Set the toilet bowl

Carefully lower the toilet bowl onto the wax ring, making sure the mounting bolts pass through the holes in the base of the toilet. Press down to compress the wax ring.

4. Secure the toilet bowl

Place a washer and nut on each mounting bolt and tighten them to secure the toilet bowl to the floor. Be careful not to overtighten and crack the toilet.

5. Install the tank

Set the tank onto the bowl, aligning it with the mounting holes. Insert bolts and tighten to secure.

6. Connect water supply

Attach the water supply line to the fill valve at the bottom of the tank and tighten.

7. Install toilet seat

Follow the manufacturer’s instructions to attach the toilet seat.

8. Test your work

Turn on the water supply to fill the tank. Flush the toilet to check for leaks around the base and water connection.