Wood Shake vs Wood Shingle Roof: 5 Remarkable Differences

Selecting the appropriate roofing material is essential for any homeowner who wishes to protect their investment and ensure lasting value. Wood shakes and wood shingles are both popular choices for their natural beauty and durability, but understanding the key differences between these two materials can make all the difference in your decision.

In this article, we’ll delve into the critical differences between wood shake and wood shingle roofs, as well as provide a comprehensive comparison to make an informed choice.

5 Remarkable differences between wood shake and wood shingle roofs

1. Thicker and rustic vs. thinner and even: The appearance factor

Wood shakes and wood shingles differ significantly in their appearance. Wood shingles have a more regulated and uniform look, with a smooth and even surface. On the other hand, wood shakes boast a unique texture that adds a charming rustic appeal to any home. The irregular thickness of wood shakes creates a visually striking effect that many homeowners find appealing.

When considering which roofing material to choose, you have to consider the overall aesthetic you desire for your home. If you prefer a more traditional and refined appearance, wood shingles might be the ideal choice. However, if you’re seeking a natural and rustic charm, wood shakes can provide that distinct character that sets your home apart.

2. Handcrafted authenticity vs. machine-made precision: The manufacturing process

One fascinating aspect that sets wood shakes and wood shingles apart is their manufacturing process. Wood shingles are typically machine-made, ensuring precise dimensions and uniformity. This manufacturing method allows for consistent quality and ease of installation.

In contrast, skilled artisans use power tools to craft wood shakes. The hands-on approach infuses each shake with a touch of authenticity and craftsmanship. The artisan’s expertise ensures that every shake possesses its own unique character and texture, adding an artisanal charm to your roof.

3. Wind and water resistance: The battle of durability

When it comes to durability, wood shakes have the upper hand in terms of wind and water resistance. Their thicker profile provides enhanced protection against high winds and heavy rainfall. The overlapping installation style of wood shakes creates a barrier that effectively prevents water penetration, making them an excellent choice for areas prone to severe weather conditions.

On the other hand, wood shingles offer respectable durability but may be less effective in extreme weather conditions. Proper installation and regular maintenance are important to maintain the longevity of wood shingles, especially in areas with intense wind or heavy rain.

4. Cost considerations: Shakes vs. shingles

Cost is an essential factor to consider when deciding between wood shakes and wood shingles for your roof. Cedar shakes tend to be more expensive compared to cedar shingles due to their manufacturing process and thicker nature. However, you need to remember that pricing can vary depending on location, availability, and other factors.

While the upfront cost of cedar shakes might be higher, you have to weigh this against their potential lifespan and durability. Investing in a long-lasting roofing material like cedar shakes can provide cost savings in the long run by reducing the need for frequent replacements or repairs.

5. Longevity: From generation to generation

The lifespan of a roof is a significant consideration for homeowners. In this regard, cedar shakes have an impressive advantage over cedar shingles. A well-maintained cedar shake roof can last up to 50 years, offering exceptional longevity that can span multiple generations.

However, proper maintenance is key to extending the lifespan of any roofing material. Regular inspections, cleaning, and necessary repairs will help make sure your wood shake or wood shingle roof remains in optimal condition for decades to come.

The role of manufacturing in wood shakes and wood shingles

Wood shingles are typically machine-made, ensuring precise dimensions and a consistent appearance. Machine manufacturing allows for uniformity in thickness and size, making installation easier and more efficient. This process involves cutting the wood into precise shapes and edges, resulting in shingles with an even and regulated look.

On the other hand, wood shakes are handcrafted using power tools by skilled artisans. This hands-on approach adds an element of authenticity and craftsmanship to each shake. The artisan’s expertise and attention to detail make sure every shake possesses its own unique texture and character. Handcrafted wood shakes have a thicker profile compared to shingles, giving them a more rustic and natural appearance.

While wood shingles offer the advantages of precision and ease of installation, wood shakes stand out for their artisanal charm and individuality. The manufacturing process for each type of roofing material contributes to their distinct characteristics, allowing homeowners to choose based on their desired aesthetic and preference for either a refined or rustic look.

Size comparison: Wood shakes and wood shingles

Wood shingles are typically thinner compared to wood shakes and have a more even and consistent appearance. The uniform thickness of shingles allows for precision during installation, resulting in a clean and polished look on the roof. This consistency in size also contributes to the ease of handling and laying shingles during the roofing process.

On the other hand, wood shakes are thicker and have a more substantial profile. The varying thickness of the shakes adds to their rustic charm and creates a visually striking effect on the roof. This unique texture and dimension give wood shakes a distinct character that sets them apart from shingles.

However, the irregular thickness of the shakes can pose challenges during installation, requiring careful placement and adjustment to achieve a balanced and aesthetically pleasing result.

Understanding the water resistance of wood shakes

Wood shakes excel in terms of water resistance, making them a suitable choice for areas with high rainfall or frequent exposure to moisture. The inherent properties of the wood used in shakes, such as cedar, spruce, redwood, cypress, and treated pine, contribute to their ability to withstand water. The handcrafted nature of wood shakes allows for a tight fit during installation, reducing the chances of water infiltration.

The overlapping installation style of wood shakes creates a natural barrier that effectively repels water and prevents it from seeping through the roof. This feature is particularly beneficial in regions prone to heavy rainfall or strong winds. The thicker profile of wood shakes also adds to their water resistance by providing an additional layer of protection against potential leaks.

However, proper maintenance and regular inspections are essential to maximize the water resistance of wood shakes. Over time, exposure to the elements can cause wear and tear, leading to potential vulnerabilities. Prompt repairs, periodic cleaning, and treatments with preservatives can help prolong the lifespan and enhance the water resistance of wood shake roofs.

Unveiling the appearance of wood shingles and wood shakes

Wood shingles and wood shakes have distinct appearances that can greatly impact the overall aesthetic of a home. Wood shingles are known for their more regulated and uniform look. They are machine-made, resulting in precisely cut pieces of wood that are consistent in size and shape. This uniformity creates a clean and polished appearance on the roof, with shingles neatly aligned in rows.

In contrast, wood shakes boast a unique texture that sets them apart. Wood shakes have a more rustic and natural appeal when they are hand-crafted using power tools. The artisanal process introduces slight variations in size, thickness, and texture, giving each shake its own individual character. These irregularities create a visually striking roofscape with a charmingly uneven surface.

The distinct appearance of wood shakes can add warmth and character to a home’s exterior. The varying thickness and unique textures create depth and visual interest, making the roof a standout feature. Wood shingles, with their precise dimensions and even appearance, offer a more refined and contemporary look that can complement a range of architectural styles.

Why do wood shakes cost more than wood shingles?

One of the primary reasons for the price difference is the manufacturing process. Typically, skilled artisans use power tools to handcraft wood shakes, which involves more labor-intensive work than the machine-made production of wood shingles. The craftsmanship involved in creating wood shakes adds to their uniqueness and artisanal appeal, thus contributing to their higher cost.

The thicker profile of wood shakes requires more wood material compared to wood shingles, leading to increased material costs. The selection of high-quality wood species, such as cedar, spruce, redwood, cypress, or treated pine, can also contribute to the higher price point of wood shakes.

Moreover, the durability and longevity of wood shakes play a role in their cost. Wood shakes are known for their ability to withstand harsh weather conditions and offer an extended lifespan of up to 50 years with proper maintenance. This longevity, along with their distinctive appearance, adds value to wood shakes but also increases their price compared to wood shingles.

A closer look at the lifespan of cedar shake roofs

Cedar shake roofs are renowned for their impressive lifespan, offering long-lasting durability and beauty to homes. While the actual lifespan can vary depending on various factors, a well-maintained cedar shake roof can typically last anywhere from 30 to 50 years, or even longer in some cases.

First, the quality of the cedar shakes themselves plays a significant role. High-quality cedar shakes that are properly sourced and installed tend to have a longer lifespan. Factors such as climate, exposure to sunlight, humidity levels, and regular maintenance practices can impact the longevity of the roof.

In regions with milder climates and less severe weather conditions, cedar shake roofs have the potential to reach the upper end of the lifespan range. With proper care, including regular inspections, prompt repairs, and periodic cleaning to remove debris and prevent moisture buildup, cedar shake roofs can endure for several decades.

However, in areas with more extreme climates characterized by intense heat, heavy rainfall, or frequent storms, the lifespan of cedar shake roofs may fall within the lower end of the range. In these scenarios, it becomes even more crucial to implement proactive maintenance measures and seek professional advice to make sure the roof remains in optimal condition. For example, in a coastal area with high humidity and saltwater exposure, a cedar shake roof may require more frequent maintenance to combat the effects of corrosion and moisture damage.

In contrast, a home located in a dry desert climate may benefit from additional measures such as applying protective coatings to prolong the lifespan of the roof.

A cost-benefit analysis between wood shakes and wood shingles

When considering the cost-benefit analysis between wood shakes and wood shingles, several factors come into play. Wood shakes generally have a higher upfront cost compared to wood shingles due to their handcrafted nature and thicker profile. However, you need to look beyond the initial investment and consider the long-term benefits.

One key advantage of wood shakes is their durability and longevity. A well-maintained cedar shake roof can last up to 50 years or more, whereas wood shingles typically have a lifespan of around 20 to 30 years. This extended lifespan can result in significant cost savings over time, as fewer replacements or repairs are needed.

Moreover, wood shakes offer superior water and wind resistance compared to wood shingles. Their thicker profile and overlapping installation style provide enhanced protection against harsh weather conditions, potentially reducing the risk of damage and associated repair costs.

In terms of aesthetics, wood shakes have a unique texture and rustic charm that many homeowners find appealing. They can add character and value to a home’s exterior, potentially enhancing its overall market value. Wood shingles, on the other hand, provide a more refined and uniform appearance suitable for various architectural styles.

However, wood shakes may require more maintenance compared to wood shingles. Regular inspections, cleaning, and treatments with preservatives are necessary to ensure their longevity and resistance against moisture and pests.

How to maintain your wood shake or wood shingle roof

  1. Regular inspections: Conduct routine inspections of your roof to identify any signs of damage, such as cracked or split shakes or shingles, loose fasteners, or areas of wear. Inspections help catch issues early on, preventing further damage and costly repairs.
  2. Clear debris: Remove leaves, branches, and other debris that accumulate on your roof. Debris can trap moisture and promote the growth of moss or algae, which can deteriorate the wood over time. Use a soft-bristle broom or leaf blower to gently clear the roof surface.
  3. Trim overhanging branches: Trim back tree branches that hang over your roof. Branches can rub against the roof, causing damage to the shakes or shingles or providing a pathway for pests to access your home.
  4. Clean gutters: Clear your gutters and downspouts regularly to ensure proper drainage. Clogged gutters can lead to water overflow, which can damage the wood and compromise the roof’s integrity.
  5. Prevent moss and algae: If you notice moss or algae growth on your roof, consider using a specialized cleaner or treatment designed for wood roofs. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions and avoid using harsh chemicals that could harm the wood.
  6. Address moisture issues: Make sure there’s proper ventilation in your attic to prevent excess moisture buildup. Moisture can lead to rot and other issues that compromise the integrity of the wood shakes and shingles. Consider installing vents or a dehumidifier, if needed.
  7. Repair or replace damaged shakes or shingles: Promptly repair or replace any damaged or missing shakes or shingles. This helps maintain the structural integrity of the roof and prevents water infiltration.
  8. Apply preservatives: Periodically apply wood preservatives or treatments recommended for shakes or shingles. These products help protect the wood from moisture, UV rays, and other environmental factors.
  9. Professional maintenance: Consider hiring a professional roofing contractor for periodic inspections and maintenance. They have the expertise to identify potential issues and perform any necessary repairs or treatments.

When and why to choose wood shingle over shake (and vice versa)

  • If you prefer a more uniform and refined appearance for your roof, choose wood shingles. Their machine-made precision results in an even and consistent look, suitable for homes with a contemporary or classic architectural style.
  • If you desire a rustic and textured aesthetic that adds character to your home, opt for wood shakes. The handcrafted nature of wood shakes provides a unique and artisanal charm, making them ideal for homes with a natural or cottage-style ambiance.
  • If you prioritize ease of installation and a more cost-effective roofing option, consider wood shingles. Their uniform dimensions and machine-made production facilitate straightforward installation, potentially reducing labor costs.
  • If you value durability, longevity, and enhanced resistance to wind and water, favor wood shakes. Their thicker profile and overlapping installation style offer superior protection against harsh weather conditions, making them suitable for areas prone to inclement weather.
  • If you are willing to invest in a roofing material with an extended lifespan and potential long-term cost savings, select wood shakes. While they may have a higher upfront cost, their durability and longevity make them a valuable investment for the future.
  • If you prefer a roofing material that requires minimal maintenance and upkeep, lean towards wood shingles. Their machine-made precision and even appearance may result in lower maintenance requirements compared to wood shakes.

In recent years, innovations and trends in wood shingle and wood shake roofing have focused on enhancing sustainability, durability, and architectural versatility.

One notable trend is the integration of environmentally friendly practices, such as sourcing wood from sustainably managed forests and utilizing eco-friendly treatments and finishes. Advancements in wood treatment technologies have led to improved fire resistance and enhanced protection against decay, expanding the practicality of wood shingle and shake roofing in various regions.

Architectural trends have seen a resurgence of interest in natural and rustic aesthetics, driving the popularity of wood shakes with their unique textures and artisanal appeal.

Furthermore, the blending of traditional craftsmanship with modern installation techniques has allowed for the creation of innovative roof designs that complement contemporary and eco-conscious architectural styles. As sustainability and natural aesthetics continue to be prioritized in the construction industry, wood shingle and shake roofing are poised to further evolve with a focus on eco-friendly practices, longevity, and design flexibility.

Author: Logan

I help people connect with businesses